I have commented this in the past, here and other places…….automatic updates are bad.

1) You, as the admin of your site, should be there in front of your computer/laptop/etc…and do the updates, to fix things in case the update(s) screw up your site.
2) If you offer site maintenance for clients and all you do is rely on automatic updates then you are not really maintaining your site.

Imagine if Amazon were to rely on automatic updates for whatever runs their site and things go down.

No plugin or theme should ever turn ON automatic updates.